Jen's Rating:

3.0

Back on course, in Aslan they trust.

Who’s In It: Georgie Henley, Skandar Keynes, Ben Barnes, Will Poulter, Anna Popplewell, William Moseley, Tilda Swinton, Simon Pegg, Liam Neeson

The Basics: Younger Pevensies Lucy (Georgie Henley) and Edmund (Skandar Keynes) are called back to Narnia with their snotty cousin Eustace (Will Poulter) in tow, where they find themselves playing hero again alongside Prince Caspian (Ben Barnes). On the trail of seven missing Lords, the gang investigates a mysterious evil mist that’s been kidnapping the innocent citizens of Narnia, facing their own battles with temptation along the way.

What’s The Deal: Lightening the mood from its violent predecessor (2008’s The Chronicles of Narnia: Prince Caspian), the series’ third outing finds more agile footing as a rousing children’s adventure – even if the plot is clumsily adapted from C.S. Lewis’s source novel. Packed to the brim with good old-fashioned questing, mystical creatures and magical tests, The Voyage of the Dawn Treader's script also has an unfortunate video-game feel thanks to a tacked-on mission involving a never-explained evil mist that can only be defeated by collecting seven magical swords from the far reaches of the world. (Clunky CG animation and 3D conversion with no added value don't help.) But while the film could easily just jump from one magical adventure/swordfight/dragon flight to the next, director Michael Apted manages to keep the focus on his young heroes as they learn their lessons; in doing so he sets the film franchise back on course, positioned as the faith-oriented family series it was meant to be.

Why The Narnia Films Are So Dependable: They’re perfectly safe moral lessons disguised as fantastical adventure, crafted in handsome detail with a wholesome nostalgic feel. They teach kids that people die (and are sometimes, you know, reborn), and that before you can enjoy grown-up things you’ve got to do a little growing up yourself. Dawn Treader hits all of the major series points, even if the proceedings are vanilla-flavored and occasionally snooze-inducing. (Word of advice: Take your bathroom break during the slow and talky first third of the film.)

Who Steals The Movie: Forget handsome Ben Barnes, who set Susan’s heart aflutter in Prince Caspian. The cast member who makes the splashiest impression is youngster Will Poulter as Lucy and Edmund’s disdainful cousin, Eustace Scrubb. (He had a similarly impactful turn playing a whip-smart delinquent in the excellent British comedy Son of Rambow.) Meanwhile, little Georgie Henley, growing more beautiful and assured with each Narnia film, steps out of the shadows of her on-screen elder siblings to lead the ensemble.

Where Dawn Treader Ups The Ante: In its Christian messaging. Always present in Lewis’s source novels, the faith element is much more pronounced here especially when it comes to Aslan (voiced once more by Liam Neeson) and what he represents. As a result, the kids learn lessons about vanity, jealousy, greed, bad behavior, and what it means when a loved one goes to “Aslan’s country,” never to be seen in life again.

Share
RSS RSS

Comments (7)

Steve - 12-10-2010 3:01 PM
Flag This Comment

CS Lewis started out being an atheist, but then converted to Christianity. He was a devout Christian for the majority of his life. He even wrote a book "Mere Christianity" where he tries to explain in a very practical way, how Jesus had to be the son of God. CS Lewis even wrote that Aslan represents Jesus. Robbie, get your facts straight before you write your immature rubbish.

Gman - 12-10-2010 6:43 PM
Flag This Comment

Robbie you have the right to believe what you want to believe. If you dont believe in Jesus or God thats your business. But you are wrong to throw your abusive comments about someone else beliefs "Jesus Poop". Those type of opinions could be kept to yourself. I'm a Christian and I would've found it wrong if someone cursed you for what ever faith (or none faith) you have. So please show respect to others. Because at the end of the day you would like someone to show it to you.

Alfonso - 12-10-2010 10:20 PM
Flag This Comment

He wasn't atheist when he wrote the chronicles. He was around 33 when he became Anglican. Sad that so many people need to cling to religion though. What makes one right and the other wrong? My religion is "be nice to people and animals" and try to explain things scientifically.

amanda - 12-13-2010 3:29 PM
Flag This Comment

i totally agree :)

amanda - 12-13-2010 3:29 PM
Flag This Comment

i totally agree :)

Krystal - 12-15-2010 2:39 AM
Flag This Comment

I saw this in 3d and liked it least of the three... not by a lot but enough. I did like that Caspian dropped his 'Spanish' accent that he had in the previous film. I think the 'green mist' is what initially turned me off.. it looked soo fake and nonthreatening. I have no problem w/morale themed movies but towards the end it was getting very corny.. and I just ended up not caring as much as the movie was trying to make me care. Thanx for the great review and keep up the good work :)

Jasmine - 12-18-2010 1:41 PM
Flag This Comment

I read the books and apparently the movie sucks? Shame! I was the 2nd best book aside from the next one which they are apparently going to make. I didn't really like the last one and, despite other's suggestions, have high hopes for this one! THey never seem to get the mvoeis quite right. Maybe it would have been better if they'd have started frmo the FIRST book. The reason they didn't do this was because books 1 and 3 preactically have nothing to do with books 2,4,5, and 6. But in book 7 (last one) every thing collides. So good luck for the producers if they make yet another!

Leave a Comment

Advertisement

Jen's recent reviews

All Jen Yamato's Movie Reviews