| Hollywood Foreign Press Association |
Witness for the Prosecution |
Best Performance by an Actor in a Motion Picture - Drama |
1957 |
Nominee |
| Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences |
Witness for the Prosecution |
Best Actor |
1957 |
Nominee |
| National Board of Review |
The Beachcomber |
Best Acting |
1938 |
Winner |
| Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences |
Mutiny on the Bounty |
Best Actor |
1935 |
Nominee |
| New York Film Critics Circle |
Ruggles of Red Gap |
Best Actor |
1935 |
Winner |
| New York Film Critics Circle |
Mutiny on the Bounty |
Best Actor |
1935 |
Winner |
| Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences |
The Private Life of Henry VIII |
Best Actor |
1932 |
Winner |